Question 1

How much does a new roof typically cost?

Accepted Answer

Roof replacement costs depend primarily on size, material, and complexity. For an average 2,000 square foot home (approximately 22 "squares" of roofing), expect: Asphalt 3-tab shingles cost $5,500-$9,000 total ($250-$400 per square), architectural shingles $7,500-$13,000 ($350-$600 per square), metal roofing $14,000-$30,000 ($600-$1,200 per square), tile roofing $16,000-$35,000 ($700-$1,500 per square), and slate roofing $25,000-$50,000+ ($1,000-$2,000+ per square). These prices include removal of one layer of old roofing, new underlayment, drip edge, ridge vents, and installation labor. Additional costs may include: structural repairs if decking is damaged ($50-$100 per sheet), chimney flashing ($300-$600), skylight replacement or resealing ($400-$1,000 each), and permit fees ($200-$500). Steep-pitch or complex roofs with multiple valleys, dormers, or difficult access add 10-25% to labor costs. Geographic location significantly impacts pricing - expect to pay 20-40% more in high-cost metropolitan areas.

Question 2

How long does a roof last and what affects its lifespan?

Accepted Answer

Roof lifespan varies dramatically by material and conditions. ASPHALT SHINGLES: 3-tab shingles last 15-20 years, architectural (dimensional) shingles 20-30 years, premium/luxury shingles 25-35 years. Most common roofing material due to cost-effectiveness ($250-$600 per square installed). METAL ROOFING: Steel lasts 40-70 years, aluminum 40-50 years, copper 70-100+ years, zinc 80-100+ years. Higher upfront cost ($600-$1,400 per square) but longest-lasting options. TILE ROOFING: Clay tile lasts 50-100+ years, concrete tile 40-50 years. Extremely durable in hot, dry climates. Heavy (requires structural support) and expensive ($700-$1,500 per square). SLATE: Natural slate lasts 75-150+ years, the longest-lasting roofing material. Very expensive ($1,000-$3,000 per square) and heavy, but outlasts multiple asphalt roof cycles. FACTORS AFFECTING LIFESPAN: Climate impact - Extreme heat (Southwest) reduces lifespan 20-30%, freeze-thaw cycles stress materials, high humidity promotes algae/moss growth. Installation quality - Proper ventilation extends life 30-50%, correct nailing prevents premature failure, adequate underlayment protects decking. Maintenance - Annual inspections catch issues early, prompt repairs prevent expansion of damage, cleaning removes damaging debris. Pitch/slope - Steeper roofs shed water better (longer life), low-slope roofs hold moisture (shorter life). Exposure - South-facing slopes age faster (more UV), tree coverage promotes moss but reduces UV damage. COLOR: Dark shingles absorb more heat (age 10-15% faster than light colors in hot climates).

Question 3

What time of year is best for roof replacement?

Accepted Answer

BEST SEASONS: Late spring (May-June) and early fall (September-October) offer optimal roofing weather. Moderate temperatures (50-80°F) allow shingles to seal properly, low humidity and precipitation reduce delays, longer daylight hours enable faster work, and comfortable conditions for crews improve quality. SUMMER (July-August): PROS - Predictable weather (less rain delay risk), fastest installation due to heat activation of adhesive strips, contractor availability often better. CONS - Extreme heat makes attic work dangerous (120-140°F), shingles can be damaged by walking on them when very hot, higher demand may increase prices 10-15%, workers fatigue faster potentially impacting quality. STILL ACCEPTABLE but schedule early morning starts. WINTER (December-February): CHALLENGING in northern climates - Shingles become brittle below 40°F, adhesive strips don't activate properly (hand-sealing required, adding $500-$1,500), frequent weather delays extend timeline, dangerous working conditions on icy/snowy roofs. Some roofers offer 10-20% winter discounts due to slow season, but quality risks often outweigh savings. ACCEPTABLE in mild winter climates (South, Southwest). SPRING (March-April): Good conditions but STORM SEASON in many areas - High demand drives up prices 15-25%, longer wait times (book 4-8 weeks ahead), spring storms may delay project. Still good choice if scheduled early. EMERGENCY REPLACEMENTS: Any season when necessary, but expect premium pricing (15-30% higher) for urgent winter work. TIMING STRATEGY: Book 8-12 weeks ahead for summer/fall installation to secure pricing and schedule, avoid June-July peak pricing, and take advantage of end-of-season sales (November-December booking for spring installation).

Question 4

Is metal roofing worth the higher cost?

Accepted Answer

Metal roofing costs 2-3× more than asphalt ($600-$1,400 vs $350-$600 per square) but offers significant advantages. METAL ROOFING BENEFITS: Longevity - 40-70 years (outlasts 2-3 asphalt roofs), energy efficiency - reflects heat saving 10-25% on cooling costs, fire resistance - Class A rating (best), wind resistance - withstands 120-180 mph winds (excellent for hurricane/tornado zones), low maintenance - no moss, algae, or rot issues, environmentally friendly - often 25-60% recycled content and fully recyclable, weight - 1/3 to 1/2 weight of tile (no structural concerns), snow shedding - excellent for snowy climates. LIFETIME COST ANALYSIS: 2,000 sq ft home (22 squares) over 60 years: ASPHALT - 3 replacements at $9,000 each = $27,000 total. METAL - 1 installation at $19,000 = $19,000 total plus energy savings $150-$400 annually ($9,000-$24,000 over 60 years). Net savings: $17,000-$32,000 with metal. BEST FOR: Long-term homeowners (10+ years to recover premium), harsh climates (extreme weather, high winds, hail), energy-conscious buyers, and eco-friendly focus. NOT IDEAL FOR: Short-term ownership (won't recover premium), tight budgets (need financing for higher cost), historic homes (modern appearance may clash), and noise-sensitive occupants (rain louder on metal, though insulation helps). NOISE CONCERN: Metal is louder than asphalt during rain/hail, but proper underlayment and insulation reduce this significantly. Most owners adapt quickly. STYLES AVAILABLE: Standing seam (most popular, modern look), corrugated (barnyard style), metal shingles (mimics slate/shake), and metal tiles (traditional appearance). RESALE: Increasingly popular with buyers, good ROI in most markets (65-75% cost recovery), excellent selling point for energy-efficient homes.

Roofing Cost Calculator

Roof Details

Roofing Quick Facts

Cost-Saving Tips

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does a new roof typically cost?

How long does a roof last and what affects its lifespan?

What time of year is best for roof replacement?

Is metal roofing worth the higher cost?